WHAT IS THE NOTWITHSTANDING CLAUSE?
In the context of Canadian constitutional law, the “notwithstanding clause” refers to section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which is part of the Constitution Act, 1982. This provision allows federal or provincial governments to pass laws that temporarily override certain rights and freedoms guaranteed by the charter.
The notwithstanding clause allows legislatures to explicitly “Opt out” of the application of certain sections of the charter, particularly the fundamental freedoms (section 2), legal rights (sections 7–14), and equality rights (section 15). In essence, it grants the government the ability to pass laws that violate certain charter rights for up to five years.
Many legal scholars and critics argue that the notwithstanding clause undermines the fundamental principles of constitutional protection for rights. Some worry that it allows governments to trample on rights without proper judicial oversight.
To be clear, the use of the notwithstanding clause is a nuclear option and the government’s way of sidestepping fundamental rights.
THE THREAT HERE AT HOME
Recently, news stories have reported that the mayor of St. Catharines supported the suspension of the charter. Let’s discuss Mat Siscoe’s contradictory statements.
St. Catharines mayor Mat Siscoe has been on record as saying ‘the city shouldn’t tear down encampments if there is nowhere for unhoused people to go.‘ The mayor has also been very public in recent days about his support of suspending the rights of unhoused individuals.
Mat claims that he ‘wants the ability to move encampments out of sensitive areas‘ like near schools or up against residential homes. However, where in the city is both “out of sensitive areas” but also provides access to the daily services many of these marginalized and vulnerable individuals need?
Mat doesn’t have an answer for that.
I plan on putting together a longer episode for my UNHOUSED series that will discuss the hypocrisy of Mat Siscoe, the City of St. Catharines, and the many well-documented failures of our municipal governments here in Niagara to come up with solutions to our growing poverty and homelessness, and addiction issues.
Regrettably, the city’s leadership lacks competence or is driven by motives that raise serious ethical concerns. They seem to possess only a superficial grasp of the underlying issues related to poverty, and they appear unaware of the implications of the notwithstanding clause and its potential misuse for ulterior purposes.
JUSTICE ENDS WHERE POLICING BEGINS: The Shameful History of Policing The Gay and Trans Community in Canada
Policing reform is routinely framed as a matter of training, oversight, or inclusive language. None of this resolves the central contradiction exposed by decades of violence against trans people: policing is a system built on discretion, not equality. It decides who belongs, who is suspect, and whose suffering is credible.
ROT AT THE CORE: How Transphobia Persists in Niagara’s Policing Culture
The former president of the Niagara Regional Police Association exemplifies systemic transphobia and homophobia in policing, perpetuating a culture of distrust. This issue highlights accountability failures, emphasizing the need for broader community responsibility in ensuring respect and equality for marginalized groups.
STEADY, UNBROKEN: A River of Reconciliation
This piece reflects on the significance of National Day for Truth and Reconciliation, emphasizing the importance of listening to land, honoring Indigenous truths, and taking action towards reconciliation. The author highlights personal experiences along the Grand River, advocating for stewardship and shared responsibility.
- I DIDN’T PLAN TO BECOME A TEACHER: The Students Who Made Me Stay
- JUSTICE ENDS WHERE POLICING BEGINS: The Shameful History of Policing The Gay and Trans Community in Canada
- RAISED BY PLACES UNSEEN: The Quiet Way Borneo Found Me
- ALONE AGAINST THE SYSTEM: Fighting Police Misconduct in Ontario Means Surviving It
- PART 3 – NO PERMISSION NEEDED: What Was Once Shame Has Become Pride
Sabrina Constance 